Skip to content
ERPCRMCosts & Decision

Custom ERP and CRM or Primavera, PHC and SAP: How to Decide

Market products are the right choice in most cases. The three signs they stopped fitting, and why the right decision is rarely to replace everything.

Custom ERP and CRM or Primavera, PHC and SAP: How to Decide
In this article
  1. What a market product does better
  2. The sign the product stopped fitting
  3. The three situations where building pays off
  4. What is usually the right decision
  5. How to know which side you are on

Anyone looking for a business management system in Portugal ends up at the same names: Primavera, PHC, Sage, and for larger companies SAP. They are mature products and, in most cases, the right choice. It is worth understanding when they are not.

What a market product does better

An off-the-shelf ERP brings decades of finished work: accounting compliant with Portuguese law, communication with the tax authority, automatic legal updates, a partner network that knows how to implement it. Building that from scratch would be absurd and we recommend it to nobody.

If your operation fits the product model, buying is cheaper, faster and less risky. Full stop.

The sign the product stopped fitting

The symptom is always the same and easy to recognise: there are parallel spreadsheets nobody can eliminate.

The ERP handles invoicing and accounting, but site cost control lives in a sheet. Or production planning. Or commission calculation. Someone maintains that sheet, everyone depends on it, and it never enters the system because the system has nowhere to put it.

When that happens, the company is paying twice: the product licence and the time of whoever maintains what the product does not do.

The three situations where building pays off

Customisation costs more than the product. When the customisation budget for an ERP exceeds the cost of building the specific module from scratch, the maths has flipped.

Per-user licensing becomes heavy. Products charge per user. If you want to give access to fifty people on the shop floor or on site, the recurring cost can quickly exceed the one-off investment in your own system.

The integrations you need do not exist. If you are going to have to commission custom integrations anyway, part of the product advantage has gone.

What is usually the right decision

In most cases it is not replacement. It is keeping accounting and invoicing in the product you already use, and building custom only the layer where the pain is: site control, production planning, CRM, client portal. That layer connects to the existing product and eliminates the parallel spreadsheets.

It is cheaper than a full migration, carries far less risk and solves the real problem.

How to know which side you are on

Add up what you spend today on licences, on customisations and on the time of whoever maintains the parallel spreadsheets. If that total exceeds the cost of building the missing layer, the decision is clear without further analysis.

In the diagnosis we run that calculation with you, and we say when the answer is to stay with the product you already have.

Neumotik

Ready to implement in your company?

We develop custom software that solves exactly the problems described in this article. Free diagnosis, no commitment.